Wednesday, February 11, 2009
« National Economy | Main | Taxation »

It's Time.

On the 11th December 2007 the Minister for Education, Employment, Workplace Relations and Social Inclusion declared a moratorium on new companies joining the Commonwealth’s workers compensation scheme, Comcare, as self insurers.

 

In late January 2008, the Minister announced a review of the Comcare scheme.  More than twelve months later and the review is still not completed and if it has been, then the Minister appears to be in no hurry to release its findings.

 

The government certainly mouths the right platitudes about the need for a more ‘seamless’ national economy.  During debate of the government’s Safe Work Australia Bill (2008), which abolishes the Coalition’s Australian Safety Compensation Council and replaces it with the equally useless Safe Wok Australia, government MPs spoke of the need for removing duplication in the areas of OHS and workers’ compensation.

 

Bill Shorten said (the Rudd government has) ‘set itself the task of creating a seamless national economy, unhampered by unnecessary duplication, overlap and indifference’.

 

Greg Combet observed that with ‘so many different jurisdictions the 39,000 companies operating across multiple jurisdictions face significant costs in complying with fundamentally different rules and regulations.’

 

Lindsay Tanner, in a speech to the parliament on the 9th February 2006, said that the various workers compensation schemes are a ‘hodgepodge of bits and pieces’ and that we are still in the ‘Dark Ages’ in spite of the efforts of the Whitlam government in 1975 to introduce a uniform national compensation scheme.’

 

To invoke a well known Whitlamism, ‘It’s time’ for Minister Gillard to end the moratorium on companies being able to join the Comcare scheme and to seriously examine the creation of a genuine national workers’ compensation and OHS scheme.  Agitate has already demonstrated how this can be done. 

 

Failure to act and provide regulatory relief for companies operating across multiple and disparate jurisdictions will continue to result in a dead weight economic loss to the Australian economy.  Resources that are wasted on complying with unnecessary and duplicative regulatory requirements are those which are not available for investment in more productive endeavours.  Even during prosperous economic times this is unacceptable.  As we enter a severe economic downturn, it is not just unacceptable but diabolical for the government to stall on this much needed reform.

 

Wednesday, February 11, 2009 9:20:52 AM (AUS Eastern Standard Time, UTC+10:00)  #    Disclaimer  |  Comments [2]  | 
Wednesday, December 12, 2012 9:09:58 PM (AUS Eastern Standard Time, UTC+10:00)
I agree with your comments Kevin and I bvleiee Comcare deserves to be congratulated for putting on the forum. It was booked out and that reflects the desire from many organisations for more information and a greater understanding of what the changes will really mean for them.I think an interesting aspect of the change for Comcare which you refer to is that legislatively their inspectorate' has not been empowered under their Act to utilise the range of powers available to an inspector unless they have formally instituted an investigation. Removing this constraint will see a significant change in their ability to interact, advise and where necessary take some form of action.One aspect of the presentations which I found very positive was that it forced those in attendance to think about and discuss issues around how they are, or will, address implementation in their organisations. A key factor which seemed to come through in the group I participated in, as well as being evident in feedback from other groups at the end of a workshop, was the age old problem of how do we get genuine engagement from senior management. I suspect many people / organisations will leave preparation too late to effectively address issues that will arise. They will assume that the basic principles are the same, just an increase in penalties and some new powers and they will not realise for some time yet that while the fundamentals remain the same the devil is in the detail and a lot of work is required before 1 January 2012.As a final comment I must say I feel for the Comcare licensees who will be unceremoniously dumped back out of the Commonwealth scheme into the different State schemes. While for most of industry harmonisation is a positive, but very imperfect, step towards greater efficiencies, for the licencess the situation highlights just how far short of real national uniformity the compromise of harmonisation is. For all the harmony that will result, there will remain some significant areas of differences in administration, registration, enforcement and court systems. It is a sad polictical indictment that the Federal Government (both current and Howard era which allowed licensees to move in from the State system) just did not use its constitutional powers to say one national law end of story.CheersGraham
Friday, December 14, 2012 9:17:54 PM (AUS Eastern Standard Time, UTC+10:00)
kPiqqQ , [url=http://ptghfvfzgsom.com/]ptghfvfzgsom[/url], [link=http://ilitazxtrzrt.com/]ilitazxtrzrt[/link], http://srzsbdgzhlzx.com/
Name
E-mail
Home page

Comment (Some html is allowed: a@href@title, em, i, strike, u) where the @ means "attribute." For example, you can use <a href="" title=""> or <blockquote cite="Scott">.  

Enter the code shown (prevents robots):

Live Comment Preview